Gender equity at the Wilderness Medical Society: Driving change through transparency
Philadelphia | October 13, 2022
Research published in Wilderness & Environmental Medicine quantifies the Society’s and journal’s gender gap, establishing a baseline for future direction and tracking progress
To accelerate gender parity in the field of wilderness medicine, in which women are significantly underrepresented, a team of researchers analyzed the gender distribution of key leadership roles at the Wilderness Medical Society (WMS) and among authors and reviewers of content published in WMS’s official journal, Wilderness & Environmental Medicine(opens in new tab/window) (WEM). Their findings, which document past and current gender gaps, are reported in two related studies available in the current issue of WEM(opens in new tab/window), published by Elsevier.
“While gender parity in science is not a new topic, the growing emphasis on diversity and inclusion that has led many well-established academic societies and journals in science and medicine to turn their focus inward and self-examine the ways existing practices may perpetuate gender gaps inspired us to create a ‘gender report card’ for academic wilderness medicine,” explained Sarah M. Schlein, MD, Larner College of Medicine, University of Vermont, Burlington, VT, USA, one of the lead investigators. “Wilderness medicine historically has had a small portion of women in leadership and publishing roles, but despite the gender gap getting smaller, we still have important work to do. Our intent was to report the existing data, both past and current state, as an objective starting point for subsequent steps.”
“The numbers tell the story. Our findings show that fewer women than men publish, are invited to peer review, present their research, and serve in the leadership of WEM and the WMS. By drawing attention to the underrepresentation of women in wilderness medicine research and publishing, we hope to speed up the pace of change.” said Linda E. Keyes, MD, Department of Emergency Medicine, University of Colorado, Aurora, CO, USA, one of the lead investigators.
One study focused on the journal’s authors, peer reviewers, and editorial board members, and showed that while women make up about a third of WMS membership (28%) in the period from 2010-2019, they represented only:
22% of journal authors and 19% of first authors. These percentages varied from year to year but did not markedly change over time.
20% of WEM peer reviewers -- who received only 18% of WEM invitations to review.
16% of editorial board members since the journal’s inception (20% of the current board).
13%-16% of mainstage conference presenters even through women were 31% of conference presenters and 27% of WMS member conference attendees.
“What we found in WEM is very similar to what is observed in publishing in many specialties, including emergency medicine and family medicine, the two specialties most commonly represented by WMS members,” said Dr. Keyes.
The other investigation was conducted to assess gender equity at the society through leadership, recognition, and speaking opportunities. According to Dr. Schlein, “The gender distribution documented for WMS as a whole is similar to that seen at WEM. Neither reflects the gender distribution of women in medicine or those who participate in wilderness activities.”
“The greatest underrepresentation is at the higher leadership levels, which unfortunately reinforces the status quo,” commented Dr. Schlein. Women comprised only 10% of board presidents, 18% of recognition awards, and 20% of mainstage presenters were women. There has never been a female WEM Editor-In-Chief.
Opportunities for the editorial board, reviewing, and publishing on the journal side create a positive feedback loop to promotions, leadership, speaking expertise, and opportunities within the society, and vice versa. The benefits of gender diversity in science and medicine are well documented. Improved gender balance in leadership can establish norms for women early in their careers by means of role modeling and mentorship, which can have an important influence on career guidance, research productivity, and society contributions. Adding more women should not be at the exclusion of men -- opportunities can be created for all.
“Gender equity is not a zero sum game. Women make up more than half the population, and I would propose that as long as women are less than 50% in any category, we are missing out on potential talent and key contributions in any field. Ideally, the path forward includes people of all genders working together to ensure access and belonging for anyone inspired by the field of wilderness medicine. Efforts to improve diversity and inclusion will have a positive impact not only on members who are women, but will strengthen the organization as a whole,” Dr. Schlein added.
Dr. Keyes noted that societies and journals that have been successful in gender parity have set firm deadlines and have called into question commonly held assumptions and excuses to achieving equity. For example, in some publications, the adoption of double-blind peer review has led to greater publication of female authors.
“Now that we have a gender report card, we can no longer fall back on vague statements to gloss over gender gaps. It is up to us, at all levels from membership to the highest leadership, to identify goals and strategies, consider new policies and programs, and hold ourselves accountable,” Dr. Keyes commented.
The investigators performed retrospective reviews on the gender breakdown all articles published in WEM from 2010-2019, peer reviewer names from the WEM Editorial Manager database, a single-day 2020 membership snapshot, conference attendees 2012 through 2020, conference presenters from winter 2017 through winter 2021, and leadership and awards data from 1984 through 2021. The software Genderize.io was used primarily to generate probability-based binary gender categorizations (male/female) based on first names or pronoun associations.
Notes for editors
The articles are:
“Gender Distribution Associated With the Journal Wilderness & Environmental Medicine,” by Linda E. Keyes, MD; Sarah M. Schlein, MD; Alainna B. Brown, BA, NREMT; Natalya E. Polukoff, BS, BA; Alicia Byrne, BA; and Neal W. Pollock, PhD (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wem.2022.04.005(opens in new tab/window)). The article is openly available at https://www.wemjournal.org/article/S1080-6032(22)00064-3/fulltext(opens in new tab/window).
“Gender Equity in Membership, Leadership, and Award Recognition in the Wilderness Medical Society,” by Sarah M. Schlein, MD; Neal W. Pollock, PhD; Natalya E. Polukoff, BS, BA; Alainna B. Brown, BA, NREMT; Alicia Byrne, BA; and Linda E. Keyes, MD (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wem.2022.04.006(opens in new tab/window)). The article is openly available at https://www.wemjournal.org/article/S1080-6032(22)00065-5/fulltext(opens in new tab/window).
The articles appear in Wilderness & Environmental Medicine, volume 33, issue 3, published by Elsevier(opens in new tab/window).
Full text of the articles is also available to credentialed journalists upon request. Contact Theresa Monturano at +1 215 239 3711 or [email protected](opens in new tab/window) to obtain copies. Journalists wishing to interview the authors should contact Linda E. Keyes, MD, at [email protected](opens in new tab/window), or Sarah M. Schlein, MD, at [email protected](opens in new tab/window).
About Wilderness & Environmental Medicine
Wilderness & Environmental Medicine (WEM)(opens in new tab/window), the official journal of the Wilderness Medical Society, is a peer-reviewed international journal for physicians practicing medicine in austere environments. It is devoted to original scientific and technical contributions on the practice of medicine defined by isolation, extreme natural environments, and limited access to medical help and equipment. Examples of topics covered include high altitude and climbing; hypothermia and cold-induced injuries; drowning and near-drowning; hazardous plants, reptiles, insects, and marine animals; animal attacks; search and rescue.
About the Wilderness Medical Society
Founded in 1983, the Wilderness Medical Society (WMS)(opens in new tab/window) is the world's leading organization devoted to wilderness medical challenges. Wilderness medicine topics include expedition and disaster medicine, dive medicine, search and rescue, altitude illness, cold- and heat-related illness, wilderness trauma, and wild animal attacks. WMS explores health risks and safety issues in extreme situations such as mountains, jungles, deserts, caves, marine environments, and space.
As a global leader in information and analytics, Elsevier helps researchers and healthcare professionals advance science and improve health outcomes for the benefit of society. We do this by facilitating insights and critical decision-making for customers across the global research and health ecosystems. In everything we publish, we uphold the highest standards of quality and integrity. We bring that same rigor to our information analytics solutions for researchers, academic leaders, funders, R&D-intensive corporations, doctors, and nurses.
Elsevier employs 9,000 people worldwide, including over 2,500 technologists. We have supported the work of our research and health partners for more than 140 years. Growing from our roots in publishing, we offer knowledge and valuable analytics that help our users make breakthroughs and drive societal progress. Digital solutions such as ScienceDirect, Scopus, SciVal, ClinicalKey and Sherpath support strategic research management, R&D performance, clinical decision support, medical education, and nursing education. Researchers and healthcare professionals rely on over 2,800 journals, including The Lancet(opens in new tab/window) and Cell(opens in new tab/window); 46,000+ eBook titles; and iconic reference works, such as Gray's Anatomy. With the Elsevier Foundation(opens in new tab/window) and our external Inclusion & Diversity Advisory Board, we work in partnership with diverse stakeholders to advance inclusion and diversity in science, research and healthcare in developing countries and around the world.
Elsevier is part of RELX(opens in new tab/window), a global provider of information-based analytics and decision tools for professional and business customers.